Tobacco Mandarin Clones

"### The Scent Profile Khulood Gold aims for Byredo's Tobacco Mandarin, and gets surprisingly close. The opening is a burst of spiced citrus; cumin and mandarin fight for dominance, with coriander adding a herbal edge. It lacks the refined sparkle of the original. This leans slightly more "headshop" at first, though that fades quickly. The heart is where it shines. A warm, slightly smoky tobacco note emerges, smoothed by leather and a resinous labdanum. It’s comforting, inviting. The base of olibanum, sandalwood, and oud is drier and woodier than Tobacco Mandarin. The oud is subtle, adding depth rather than dominating. I’d say it’s 86% there. The synthetic edges are noticeable up close, but in the air, it captures the vibe. ### Longevity & Projection Longevity is decent. I get about 6-7 hours on skin, with moderate projection for the first 2 hours. It creates a nice scent bubble without being obnoxious. On clothing, it lasts noticeably longer, lingering for a full day. ### Bottom Line If you adore the mood of Tobacco Mandarin but balk at the price tag, Khulood Gold is a solid alternative. It’s for the person who appreciates a well-worn leather chair, a crackling fire, and the scent of exotic spices. Is the original ten times better? No. This offers a similar experience without breaking the bank. A great option for the budget-conscious fragrance enthusiast."

"### The Scent Profile Tobacco D'Feu kicks off with a blast of cumin and mandarin. It's a bit rougher around the edges than Tobacco Mandarin, more cumin-forward, and less of Byredo's signature smooth citrus. The heart transitions into a smoky tobacco and leather accord, with the labdanum adding a resinous sweetness. You definitely get the tobacco, but it's not as refined as the original. The drydown is where this clone shines. The olibanum and sandalwood provide a warm, slightly incense-like base. The oud is subtle, adding a touch of depth without being barnyardy. I'd say it captures about 88% of Tobacco Mandarin's DNA, sacrificing some of the original's finesse for a bolder opening. ### Conclusion Tobacco D'Feu is a great option It's not a perfect dupe, the opening being the biggest difference, but it captures the overall vibe. If you like cumin and enjoy a slightly more rugged take on the tobacco-mandarin combination, this is a no-brainer. This clone delivers enough of the experience . Buy it. ### Longevity & Projection This one lasts. I get a solid 7-8 hours on my skin, with moderate projection for the first 2-3 hours. After that, it sits closer to the skin but remains noticeable. It's definitely office-appropriate if sprayed lightly, but be mindful of the cumin in the opening."

"### The Scent Profile Vibrant Spicy Tobacco kicks off with a blast of spiced orange. Cumin and mandarin fight for dominance. It mimics Tobacco Mandarin's opening reasonably well—around 87% similarity. The difference? This one has a slightly sharper, more synthetic edge. Not unpleasant, just…brighter. The heart is where the tobacco surfaces. It's a drier, less sweet tobacco than the Byredo, leaning into the leather and a dusty labdanum. The base settles into a smoky incense. Olibanum takes center stage, with sandalwood offering a creamy backdrop. I detect the oud, but it’s very subtle – more of a woody nuance than a full-blown barnyard. ### Wear time & Sillage Longevity is decent. I get about 6 hours on skin with moderate projection for the first 2 hours. It softens considerably after that, becoming a skin scent. that's perfectly acceptable. ### Is it Worth It? Vibrant Spicy Tobacco is a solid option for those curious about Tobacco Mandarin but balking at the price. It captures the essence, even if it lacks the refined smoothness of the original. If you crave a sophisticated and smoother experience, Byredo is a better option. However, if you are after a reasonably-priced fragrance to explore the tobacco and mandarin genre, this is a good choice."

"### The Verdict This is a very competent clone. If you crave the Tobacco Mandarin experience without the hefty price tag, Vibrant Spicy Tobacco is a worthy contender. It's for the individual who appreciates a confident, slightly rebellious air. Someone who pairs a worn leather jacket with a devil-may-care attitude. While it doesn’t reach the heights of Byredo's creation, This is a solid alternative for those who want the vibe without breaking the bank. ### Notes & Nuances Vibrant Spicy Tobacco opens like a bustling spice market, mandarin peels mingling with the sharp tang of cumin and coriander. It's a bright, almost astringent start – not as smoothly blended as Byredo's Tobacco Mandarin. That initial blast mellows into a warm, leathery tobacco. The heart is where this clone shines, delivering a solid rendition of that comforting, subtly sweet tobacco. Labdanum adds a resinous depth. The base is less nuanced, a straightforward blend of olibanum, sandalwood, and a hint of medicinal oud. It lacks the refined elegance of the original's drydown, feeling a bit more… direct. Overall, it captures about 85% of Tobacco Mandarin’s vibe. The main difference lies in the quality of ingredients. You can detect a slight synthetic edge, particularly in the opening and the oud. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is surprisingly good. I get a solid 6-7 hours on skin. Projection is moderate for the first hour, then settles into a pleasant, personal bubble. It won't fill a room, but people close by will notice."

"### The Scent Profile Tobacco D'Feu by French Avenue aims for Byredo's Tobacco Mandarin, and hits approximately 85% of the mark. The opening presents a potent cumin note – perhaps a touch sharper and less integrated than the original. Mandarin is present, but fleeting, yielding quickly to the drier coriander. The heart showcases a tobacco accord, undeniably synthetic, lacking the nuanced depth of Byredo's iteration. Leather is discernible but remains subdued. Labdanum contributes a resinous sweetness, attempting to soften the synthetic edges. The base features olibanum, providing a smoky incense. Sandalwood offers a creamy counterpoint, though slightly overshadowed by the oud, which leans somewhat medicinal and synthetic in this formulation. ### Final Thoughts Tobacco D'Feu is a competent attempt at cloning Tobacco Mandarin. The price point is its strongest asset. While the synthetic nature of some accords is apparent, it provides a generally pleasant experience for those seeking a tobacco-centric fragrance on a budget. If you demand photorealistic, natural ingredients, stick with Byredo. However, if you're okay with a slightly rougher approximation that captures the overall spirit, this is a worthwhile alternative. For others, this will scratch the itch effectively. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is moderate, projecting for approximately 2-3 hours before settling closer to the skin. It lasts on clothing for 6-7 hours as a skin scent. Not bad, but certainly not beast mode. Sillage is moderate initially, leaving a noticeable trail."