Mystery Tobacco Clones

"### Scent Breakdown Tobacco Myth opens with a spicy ginger kick, softened by a fruity, almost apricot-like Osmanthus note. The Davana oil adds a boozy herbal touch. It's clearly aiming for that upscale tobacco vibe of Mystery Tobacco. I'd say it gets about 87% of the way there. The heart develops a woody dryness from the vetiver and guaiac, and the patchouli is present but well-behaved. The base is where it shines; a warm, comforting tonka bean and a sweet, slightly smoky tobacco leaf. It's less complex than the original, maybe a bit more linear in the drydown. There's a slight synthetic edge in the opening, but it fades quickly. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is decent. Expect around 6-7 hours on skin, maybe a bit more on clothes. Projection is moderate for the first hour, then it settles closer to the skin. It's not a room filler, which, frankly, is a good thing. Think intimate and refined. ### Bottom Line Tobacco Myth is a solid alternative to Carolina Herrera's Mystery Tobacco. It's not a perfect dupe, but it captures the essence of the fragrance . If you're looking for a sophisticated, slightly sweet tobacco scent for fall and winter, this is a safe bet. Wear it to the office, date night, or just when you want to feel a bit more put-together."

"### First Impressions & Dry Down Charuto Mysterious Tobacco opens with a blast of ginger and something vaguely fruity, presumably the davana and osmanthus. It aims for Mystery Tobacco, and gets about 92% of the way there. The opening is sharper, more synthetic than the Carolina Herrera. The heart is where it shines. The vetiver, patchouli, and guaiac wood create a smoky, earthy base. It’s less refined than the original; a bit rougher around the edges. The drydown is the best part: tonka bean and tobacco. It's warm and comforting, but still has that synthetic edge – a reminder that this is a budget offering. The tobacco note is present, but not as rich or complex as the inspiration. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is surprisingly decent. I get about 6-7 hours on skin. Projection is moderate for the first hour, then sits closer. Not a room filler. Perfect for office or close encounters where you don't want to overwhelm. I can’t complain. ### Bottom Line Charuto Mysterious Tobacco is a good, not great, clone. If you’re curious about Mystery Tobacco but can’t stomach the price tag, this is a viable alternative. Is it a 1:1 dupe? No. Does it capture the essence? Yes, enough to satisfy. Buy this if you value saving money over ultimate refinement. The original IS smoother and more nuanced. However, difference (we're talking potentially 10x the cost!), this is a solid, everyday option."

"### How it Smells Exclusif Tabac opens with a spicy ginger kick, noticeably sharper than Carolina Herrera's Mystery Tobacco. The davana and osmanthus are present, lending a fruity, almost apricot-like sweetness, but it leans slightly synthetic. The heart develops with a drier vetiver and patchouli. It's similar to the original, but lacks the smooth, refined feel. The tobacco note in the base is good, but not quite as rich or complex. It smells like tobacco absolute, whereas the original uses something smoother. I'd say it's about 88% similar, with the main differences in the opening sharpness and the overall depth. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is surprisingly decent. I get around 6-7 hours on my skin with moderate projection for the first 2 hours. After that, it sits closer to the skin, becoming a more intimate scent. It definitely performs better than some other clones I've tried. It won't fill a room, but people close to you will notice. ### To Buy or Not to Buy? Exclusif Tabac is a solid option. If you want the nuanced refinement of Mystery Tobacco, you'll have to pay the premium. But if you're looking for a good-smelling, affordable tobacco fragrance with a spicy kick, this is a strong contender. It's not a perfect dupe, and the synthetic edges are noticeable, but it's a worthwhile alternative if you're on a budget. This gets you most of the way there ."