Red Tobacco

First Impressions & Dry Down

Alright, let's talk about this Red Tobacco clone aiming for Carlisle. The opening hits you with a spiced apple – nutmeg definitely there, but the green apple feels a bit sharper, less juicy than Carlisle's pear. The heart is where it tries to get close: tonka, a hint of rose, trying for that warm, inviting feel. Honestly, it's maybe 80% there. The drydown brings the patchouli and vanilla, and this is where the clone struggles slightly. It's a bit more synthetic, a touch rougher around the edges compared to Carlisle's smooth, almost luxurious finish.

Performance Reality Check

Performance is decent, I'll give it that. I get a solid 6-7 hours on skin, projecting moderately for the first 2-3. It's noticeable without being a room filler. Clothes? You'll smell it the next day. Not bad point.

Final Thoughts

it's a worthwhile option It's not a 1:1 dupe; it has a slightly synthetic edge, particularly in the drydown. But if you want the *impression* of Carlisle, for everyday wear, this does the trick. Is Carlisle ten times better? Probably, but is it ten times *necessary*? That depends on your budget. This Red Tobacco clone is a great daily driver, perfect for cool weather, casual evenings, or when you just want to smell good without breaking the bank. Someone starting their fragrance journey? Absolutely buy this.