Shining City

Is it Worth It?

Shining City gets you close to the City of Stars experience without breaking the bank. It’s a solid clone for those who like the vibe, but aren’t ready to spend hundreds. If you're after a dead-ringer, this isn't it. However, If you want a bright, citrusy fragrance for everyday wear, and the occasional compliment, this fits the bill. If you're on a budget and enjoy citrus, this is worth a blind buy.

First Impressions & Dry Down

Shining City copies City of Stars, aiming for that vibrant, citrus-heavy opening. You get a blast of lime and orange right away; it's undeniably similar, perhaps 92% there. The Milestone version leans a bit sharper initially, with a slightly synthetic edge to the citrus that the original avoids. The tiare flower in the heart is present, but it feels less creamy, more floral than LV’s interpretation. As it dries down, the powdery musk and sandalwood try to mimic the original's sophisticated base, but again, the lower price point shows. It lacks the smoothness and depth of the inspiration.

Performance Reality Check

Expect moderate performance. Shining City projects for about an hour, leaving a decent scent trail. Longevity is around 4-5 hours on my skin, which is acceptable . Don’t expect all-day wear.