Noir D'Arabie

Notes & Nuances

Noir D'Arabie opens with a recognizable saffron and bergamot accord. The bergamot is fleeting; the saffron, while present, lacks the nuance of the Montale original. The heart pushes forward with oud and Bulgarian rose. The oud is clearly synthetic, lacking the depth and complexity of aged natural oud. However, the rose attempts to add some much-needed smoothness. The drydown is where this clone mirrors Arabians Tonka most effectively: tonka bean and amberwood create a sweet, woody base. It's approximately 91% similar to the original but lacks the refined edges and higher quality ingredients. There's a slight harshness, a noticeable "clone" accord, particularly as it settles.

The Verdict

Noir D'Arabie offers an affordable interpretation of Arabians Tonka. If you crave that sweet, woody-oud profile but balk at the Montale price, this is a viable option. The synthetic aspects are undeniable, but the overall effect is pleasing enough for casual wear. If you demand photorealistic accuracy and superior ingredients, stick with the original. However, if you want a close approximation Noir D'Arabie delivers adequate performance and scent profile. The original IS worth the extra investment, but this is a good alternative for budget-conscious buyers.

Longevity & Projection

Performance is surprisingly potent. It projects strongly for the first 2-3 hours, creating a noticeable scent bubble. Longevity is respectable; expect to get 7-8 hours on skin. It clings to clothing for considerably longer.