
Scentonym Analysis
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
Conclusion
Shaghaf Pour Femme is a solid buy It scratches that itch without breaking the bank. Is it as luxurious as the original? No. Does it smell good and last a decent amount of time? Absolutely. If you're okay with a slightly less refined version, this is a great daily driver. If you demand perfection and the highest quality ingredients, stick with Carolina Herrera. Otherwise, save your cash and enjoy.
Scent Breakdown
Shaghaf Pour Femme definitely channels Good Girl. I'd put it at maybe 92% similar. The opening hits you with that familiar blast of almond and coffee, though the almond is slightly more prominent here, a touch sweeter. The heart of tuberose and jasmine is where it deviates a bit. It’s not quite as creamy or nuanced as the original; there's a slightly sharper floral edge. The drydown is cozy – tonka, cacao, and vanilla create a warm, inviting base. But again, the cacao feels a bit more synthetic, lacking the depth of the real deal. It's a good imitation, but not perfect.
Performance Reality Check
Longevity is surprisingly good . I get a solid 6-7 hours, which is respectable. Projection is moderate for the first 2 hours, then it settles closer to the skin. It's noticeable without being overpowering. Perfect for the office or a date night where you want to be noticed, but not announce your arrival from across the room.
Performance Audit
Based on average wear time
Sillage & radius
Relative to market avg
Why we track this:
Price Arbitrage: Significant savings compared to the original Carolina Herrera pricing.
Community Verified: Cross-referenced against 415 enthusiast votes for accuracy.