
Scentonym Analysis
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
Olfactory Experience
Great Eagle of Arabia aims for Montale's Arabians Tonka, and it gets... close. The opening blasts off with saffron and a citrus that's more generic than the original's bergamot. A synthetic oud dominates the heart. Bulgarian rose peeks through, but the oud overpowers. It's less refined and a touch screechy compared to Montale's smoother blend. Drydown brings the tonka and amberwood, creating a sweet, slightly woody base. It lands about 88% in the ballpark of Arabians Tonka, but with a noticeable synthetic edge that cheaper ingredients bring.
The Performance Stats
This stuff is a beast. Projection is strong for the first two hours. Expect a noticeable scent bubble. Longevity? Easily 8+ hours on skin, longer on clothes. One or two sprays max. More and you risk olfactory fatigue or offending those around you.
Conclusion
Is it Arabians Tonka? No. Is it a worthy substitute if you're on a budget? Absolutely. Great Eagle of Arabia delivers a powerful, long-lasting fragrance that captures the essence of the original. If you crave Arabians Tonka but can't stomach the Montale price tag (often 10x higher), this clone is a viable alternative. Just be aware of the synthetic edge and go easy on the trigger. A good option if you want the profile but prefer to buy groceries instead of niche fragrances.
Performance Audit
Based on average wear time
Sillage & radius
Relative to market avg
Why we track this:
Price Arbitrage: Significant savings compared to the original Montale pricing.
Community Verified: Cross-referenced against 371 enthusiast votes for accuracy.