Carnal Flower Clones

"### Scent Breakdown Forbidden Flower jumps right into the tuberose, that's for sure. It’s a bold, creamy white floral right off the bat, aiming for that same green, almost mentholated edge of Carnal Flower thanks to the eucalyptus. The bergamot and melon add a touch of sweetness up top, but it's mostly tuberose and that slightly medicinal eucalyptus. It lacks the refinement of the Frederic Malle; there's a slightly synthetic "shampoo-y" vibe lingering. As it dries down, the jasmine and ylang-ylang become more prominent, softening the intensity. The coconut and white musk in the base give it a slightly tropical, sunscreen feel but it’s faint. I'd say it lands around 95% close to Carnal Flower, but the opening is where the difference is most noticeable. ### Bottom Line If you're curious about Carnal Flower but balk at the price tag, Forbidden Flower is a worthwhile alternative. It captures the essence of the original without completely breaking the bank. However, the slight synthetic edge and shorter longevity might bother some. If you're looking for a nearly identical clone, you might be disappointed. But ? It's a solid warm-weather fragrance for everyday wear – think casual outings, brunch, or even the office if you go light on the trigger. For a daily driver, Forbidden Flower gets the job done. ### Performance Reality Check Okay, here's the deal. Forbidden Flower projects decently for the first hour, leaving a noticeable scent trail. After that, it settles closer to the skin. I get about 5-6 hours of wear on skin, maybe a bit longer on clothes. Not bad, but not beast mode."

"### How it Smells Oil Perfumery's "Carnal Flower Impression" aims for Frederic Malle’s iconic tuberose. The opening delivers a crisp bergamot and a noticeable eucalyptus note, lending an initial camphoraceous coolness that's similar to the original, though slightly sharper and less rounded. The melon isn't overtly fruity but adds a watery sweetness. The heart unfolds with tuberose front and center. It's a solid rendering, but lacks the creamy, almost buttery depth of the Malle. The ylang-ylang and jasmine are present, yet play supporting roles. The drydown brings forth a coconut accord. This is where the divergence from the original becomes most apparent. The Malle leans into a cleaner, almost soapy musk, whereas this clone is more tropical and overtly sweet, thanks to a pronounced orange blossom note layered atop a synthetic musk. Overall, I'd estimate this clone captures approximately 90% of the original's DNA. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is moderate. I observed around 5-6 hours on skin. Projection is initially strong for about an hour, creating a noticeable scent bubble. Then it settles closer to the skin. You will get wafts throughout the day, but it's not an overwhelming perfume. ### To Buy or Not to Buy? it's a decent approximation. The synthetic edges are noticeable, particularly in the base, but not deal-breakers. If you crave the Carnal Flower experience on a budget, this is a worthwhile option. But for casual wear, this clone scratches the itch adequately. Recommended for those who appreciate tuberose but don't want to commit to the high price point of the original."