Target Profile
The Tragedy of Lord George Clones
We found 2 verified alternatives for Penhaligon's's The Tragedy of Lord George. Compare performance, accuracy, and price below.
Tragedy
Fragrance World
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### The Scent Profile Tragedy by Fragrance World throws a boozy punch in the opening, but less cognac, more…cherry cough syrup. The medicinal edge fades quickly, thankfully, yielding to a creamy heart attempting to mimic shaving soap. It's vaguely successful, but with a synthetic sharpness, like a lemon-scented cleaning wipe. The drydown is where things truly diverge from the inspiration. Instead of a smooth tonka and amber embrace, it’s a murky base of generic woody notes, fighting against a prominent, plasticky tonka bean. Compared to what I understand of the original, this feels like a rushed, simplified imitation, lacking the nuance and depth. ### Bottom Line This scent suits someone who wants the idea of a sophisticated, boozy-barbershop fragrance, without the actual complexity or investment. Picture a young professional, perhaps a recent graduate still furnishing their apartment with IKEA, who prioritizes quantity over quality in their fragrance wardrobe. They want to smell presentable without emptying their account. ### Longevity & Projection Longevity is moderate, clocking in at around 5-6 hours. Projection starts strong, reaching about an arm's length for the first hour, then quickly settles into a skin scent. I wore this to a casual office setting and a rainy afternoon walk; it performed adequately in both, though the artificial shaving cream note became cloying in the humidity."
Noble George Privezarah
Paris Corner
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### How it Smells Noble George Privezarah opens with a boozy brandy note, yet it leans closer to cherry cough syrup than fine cognac. There's a medicinal quality that lingers, almost like a sterilized band-aid. The heart shifts quickly to the shaving soap accord – a powdery, clean aroma that evokes a vintage barbershop. However, it’s not the creamy lather one expects, but rather a drier, more chalky soap, vaguely reminiscent of old-fashioned talcum powder. The base introduces tonka bean and amber, which initially offer warmth and sweetness. Alas, the woody notes intrude with a harsh, almost plasticky edge that mars the comforting finish. This departs significantly from any sophisticated wood element. ### Longevity & Projection Longevity is moderate, clinging to skin for about 5-6 hours. Projection starts at about an arm's length, then quickly retreats to a skin scent within the first hour. It was tested in a climate-controlled office setting, and faded without any particular dynamism or sillage. ### Final Thoughts This scent is for the individual who aspires to project an aura of antiquated refinement, but hasn't quite found their footing. Picture a young history student, still clinging to their grandfather's worn leather armchair, dreaming of a bygone era, but ultimately succumbing to the synthetic realities of the present. They're more comfortable browsing antique shops online than actually engaging with the world. They appreciate the idea of a gentleman's club more than the experience itself."
About these The Tragedy of Lord George alternatives
Scentonym tracks specific batch variations and reformulation notes. The clones listed above are ranked by community verification score. Prices are updated daily from major retailers.