Y Eau de Parfum Clones

"### How it Smells Sheikh Al Shuyukh Final Edition opens with an unconvincing apple note; more like artificial green apple candy than a crisp orchard fruit. The ginger is dialed way up, adding a spicy sharpness that clashes somewhat with the citrus attempts of the bergamot. It lacks the refined sweetness present in Y. The heart is where it deviates more noticeably. The sage and geranium create a soapy, almost medicinal accord, not unpleasant, but clearly distinct. Juniper berries are present, but muted. In the drydown, the amberwood is prominent, lending a woody chemical aroma that borders on harsh. The tonka bean attempts to smooth things out with a powdery sweetness, but the cedar emerges as a dominant force, giving it a pencil shaving vibe. ### How Long Does it Last? This one lasts a solid 6-7 hours on my skin, projecting moderately for the first 2 hours, then settling closer to the skin. I tested it during a day of light activity, mostly indoors. ### Is it Worth It? Wearing this instead of Y offers a semblance of the intended scent profile, but with compromises. You gain a bolder, spicier opening, but lose the smooth sophistication of the original. The sharper, more synthetic amberwood in the drydown is a definite downgrade, sacrificing the elegant, refined finish of Y for a louder, less nuanced character. It’s an obvious stand-in, not an equivalent."

"### How it Smells Yeah! opens with an initial blast of tart green apple – specifically, Granny Smith – accented by a rather sharp ginger note that veers slightly into cleaning product territory. The bergamot is present, but subdued, adding a fleeting citrus zest that is rapidly overshadowed. The heart introduces a clary sage that is drier and more herbal than the original Y, lacking the subtle sweetness. The juniper berries contribute a slightly bitter, almost medicinal quality, while the geranium is rendered somewhat artificial, conjuring images of cheap floral soap. The base leans heavily on amberwood, resulting in an aggressively woody and somewhat synthetic drydown. The tonka bean attempts to smooth things out, but it's ultimately overpowered by the cedar, which presents a harsh, pencil shaving aroma. The overall effect is a less refined and more angular interpretation; the blended, cohesive character of the inspiration is lost in translation. ### To Buy or Not to Buy? This fragrance is best suited for casual daytime wear during the spring and fall months. Its aggressive opening might be overwhelming in close quarters or warmer weather. The composition's reliance on sharp, synthetic notes makes it better suited for outdoor, informal settings. ### How Long Does it Last? On my skin, Yeah! lasts approximately five hours, with projection extending to about one arm's length for the first hour before settling closer to the skin. I tested this in both indoor office environments and during outdoor walks in moderate temperatures."

"### The Ultimate Dumb Reach ** The Scent Profile ** Lattafa Fakhar Black is a hybrid clone, primarily targeting YSL Y EDP but mixing in elements of Invictus. It is the definition of "Blue Fragrance"—fresh, sweet, synthetic, and universally liked. The apple and ginger opening is crisp and energetic. It tones down the aggressive sage note found in YSL Y, making it smoother and slightly sweeter. It lacks the sharp, piercing metallic edge of the original, which many users actually prefer. ** Performance Reality Check ** Moderate. Unlike the "beast mode" YSL Y EDP, Fakhar sits in the 6-hour range. It projects well for the first hour but settles down quickly. It’s not a room filler, but it’s present. ** The Verdict ** The bottle looks fantastic, and the juice is the perfect "I don't know what to wear" solution. Office safe, gym safe, date safe. It’s not unique, and it won't win awards for artistic merit, but it simply smells good to everyone around you."

"### The Verdict This fragrance would suit a young man, perhaps a college student, who desires a bold, attention-grabbing scent. He probably enjoys wearing brightly colored clothing and isn't afraid to make a statement. He frequents nightclubs and prioritizes making an immediate, powerful impression. Sophistication isn't necessarily his primary goal; rather, a potent, long-lasting scent that announces his presence. ### First Impressions & Dry Down Odyssey Homme Mega charges out of the gate with a sugary apple blast, like an overly sweet green apple hard candy dropped in ginger ale. The bergamot attempts to cut through the sweetness, but the overall effect is initially cloying. The heart brings a medicinal, almost antiseptic quality – the sage and juniper clash in a way that evokes a dentist's office. This transitions into a drier, woodier base, but the amberwood dominates, lending a synthetic, harsh edge that lingers. Compared to its inspiration, it lacks the smooth, sophisticated balance, opting instead for a louder, less nuanced interpretation. The drydown sheds some of the artifice, with the cedar coming through slightly, still, it retains a faintly plasticky character, like cheap vinyl. ### Longevity & Projection Longevity is remarkable; I get a solid 8-9 hours. Projection is initially quite strong, easily filling a room for the first two hours, before settling to about an arm's length for the next few. I wore it during a casual Friday at the office, and found the initial projection a bit overwhelming in close quarters."

"### Olfactory Experience Powdery Magnolia opens with a sharp, almost astringent apple note reminiscent of green apple shampoo, quickly tempered by a candied ginger. It lacks the vibrant citrus of its inspiration. The heart is where the magnolia emerges, but it's a muted, cosmetic powder version – imagine scented baby wipes. Sage and geranium add a slightly herbal, almost soapy cleanliness, but the juniper is barely detectable. The drydown is dominated by a prominent amberwood note with a raw lumber quality, alongside a somewhat plasticky tonka bean that lacks depth. The cedar provides a dry, woody backdrop, but the overall effect is less refined. The missing citrus and aquatic nuances separate it from the original, leaving it a bit denser and less airy. ### The Performance Stats I got about 5 hours of longevity with this fragrance. The projection is initially strong, extending to about an arm's length for the first hour, then settling closer to the skin. I tested it at the gym and at the office. In a confined space like an elevator, it becomes noticeable, but it doesn't leave a lasting trail. ### Conclusion Powdery Magnolia is a good choice for casual daytime wear during spring or fall. Its clean, slightly sweet profile makes it suitable for running errands or a laid-back brunch. However, the synthetic edge prevents it from being truly versatile. It's too generic for a formal event, and lacks the sophistication for a night out."

"### Is it Worth It? Wearing Sheikh Shuyukh Final Edition instead of Y, you gain some initial similarity, a slightly different take on the aromatic heart, and decent longevity. What you lose is the refined, blended quality of the original, the fresh florals, and a natural, smoother drydown. It's a daily grab when you don't want to deplete your pricier bottles but don't expect it to fool anyone who knows the original well. ### Olfactory Experience Sheikh Shuyukh Final Edition wants to be Y, and in the opening it makes a decent effort. You get that juicy apple, tempered with a zingy ginger, although here the apple leans more toward a green Jolly Rancher than a crisp, natural fruit. The bergamot is there, but fleeting. The heart is where the similarities start to diverge. The sage and juniper are present, adding a herbal, slightly gin-like quality, but the geranium is dialed way down, losing that fresh, floral aspect of the original. The drydown is where this one falls apart. The amberwood is prominent, becoming a bit screechy and synthetic, with a plasticky cedar note that detracts from any of the warmth of the tonka bean. It's recognizable as *inspired* by Y, but certainly not a twin. It possesses a unique aromatic experience, despite the similarities. ### Wear time & Sillage This one hangs around. I get a solid 6-7 hours on my skin. Projection is moderate for the first 2 hours, extending about an arm's length, then settles closer to the skin. I wore it during a busy day of errands and it held up okay, though the synthetic notes in the drydown became more apparent as the day wore on."

"### The Scent Profile Fakhar opens with a forceful blast of synthetic apple – less orchard-fresh and more akin to a candied green apple lollipop, tempered by a fizzing ginger note. The bergamot is relegated to a faint, zesty whisper underneath. The heart introduces a coniferous juniper, offering a slightly medicinal counterpoint to the initial sweetness. Sage surfaces, but it's a restrained, almost soapy rendition, not the earthy herbaceousness one might anticipate. Geranium provides a metallic tang, bordering on tinny. The drydown leans heavily on amberwood, creating an overwhelming, arid woodiness that dominates the composition. The tonka bean is present, but muted; a powdery veil struggling to emerge from the woody onslaught. The cedar is nondescript, adding only to the overall dry, woody character. While mirroring some facets of its inspiration, it diverts substantially in its rendering of the fruit notes and the intensity of the synthetic woods. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is considerable, clocking in at 7-8 hours. Projection is strong for the first 2 hours, easily extending beyond arm's length, then gradually subsides to a closer skin scent. Tested in both indoor office environments and outdoor casual settings. ### Final Thoughts This fragrance is suited to the individual who favors bold, sweet, and woody scents. The ideal wearer might be someone who appreciates a confident, uncomplicated fragrance profile. Perhaps a young professional, early in their career, looking for a potent, attention-grabbing scent."

"### How it Smells London Saville Row Mayfair opens with an eager, almost aggressive, sweetness – think candied green apple skin rather than the juicy core. There's a fleeting ginger snap at first spray, quickly overtaken by a slightly harsh bergamot reminiscent of lemon-scented cleaning fluid. The heart attempts sophistication with sage, but it's a muted, grassy note struggling against the synthetic juniper berry that smells closer to gin-soaked cotton. Geranium provides a faint, powdery counterpoint. The drydown unfortunately reveals its true nature: amberwood creates a plasticky veneer over a simplistic tonka bean that evokes vanilla car freshener. Cedar is barely detectable, lost in the overall synthetic haze. ### Performance Reality Check Longevity is moderate, clinging to skin for about 5 hours. Projection is initially strong within an arm's length, quickly fading to a skin scent after an hour. Worn during a day of errands, it became faint and somewhat cloying by mid-afternoon, turning into a slightly sour skin musk. ### Is it Worth It? This fragrance suits someone young, eager to make an impression, perhaps a student or someone entering the workforce. They're drawn to bold scents, projecting confidence even if it's not entirely earned. This isn’t the scent for contemplative evenings or quiet sophistication, but for crowded bars and bustling city streets where its brashness can blend into the background noise."