Amber Oud Carbon

The Verdict

Amber Oud Carbon is a competent clone of Green Irish Tweed . While it doesn't perfectly capture the nuances and natural ingredients of the Creed, it delivers a respectable approximation. If you enjoy the GIT DNA but are budget-conscious, this is a viable option. However, fragrance purists should stick to the original. At this price point, the slight synthetic character is forgivable. A good choice for everyday wear.

First Impressions & Dry Down

Amber Oud Carbon attempts to replicate Creed's Green Irish Tweed, achieving approximately 86% accuracy. The opening presents a sharp lemon verbena note alongside a powdery iris. It mimics the initial freshness of GIT, but lacks the same naturalistic green bite; a slightly synthetic edge is apparent. The heart showcases violet leaf prominently. It's a decent interpretation, but the crucial crispness of the violet in GIT is subdued, replaced by a rounder, less defined green impression. The base features a blend of ambergris and sandalwood. The ambergris accord here feels more like ambroxan, providing a somewhat cleaner, less animalic drydown than the original. The sandalwood is creamy but remains in the background.

The Performance Stats

Longevity is moderate. I detected the scent for around 5-6 hours on skin with moderate projection for the first 2 hours, settling closer to the skin thereafter.