Massad

First Impressions & Dry Down

Massad opens with a notable cardamom and fig accord. The black tea is present but recessive, a subtle dryness compared to the creamier opening of Gris Charnel. The iris in the heart is detectable, a powdery counterpoint to the woody vetiver, but lacks the buttery richness of the original. It leans slightly more linear in the mid. Drydown brings forward a pleasant sandalwood-tonka combination. It attempts the cozy warmth of Gris Charnel, but with a slightly synthetic edge in the tonka. Overall, I'd place it at around 75-87% similarity. The brighter, more pronounced fig and slightly harsher tonka are the key differences.

The Performance Stats

Longevity is moderate. I get around 5-6 hours on skin, with projection strongest for the first hour before settling closer to the body. It is office safe after the first 30 minutes. Not beast mode, but acceptable .

To Buy or Not to Buy?

Massad offers a solid approximation of Gris Charnel . If you appreciate the scent profile but find the original’s price prohibitive, this is a worthwhile alternative. However, those seeking a near-identical experience will likely detect the nuances that set it apart. The original justifies its price point for its refinement, but the diminishing returns may make Massad a suitable substitute for many.