ÉCLAT 972 VIP

First Impressions & Dry Down

ÉCLAT 972 VIP throws a lot at you right away. The incense is sharp, almost acrid, like burning cheap incense sticks next to a bowl of artificial raspberry flavoring. This opening blasts for a good 15 minutes before the central oud accord develops. The oud is there, but it lacks depth; instead, it's a somewhat papery oud note, underpinned by a noticeable birch tar smokiness. The rose is quite faint, more of a suggestion than a distinct note. The drydown is where things become more problematic. The amberwood dominates, giving off a harsh, scratchy sensation with a plasticky finish that lingers unpleasantly. It bears a passing resemblance to the inspiration but lacks the nuance and smoother edges; the original is far more refined.

To Buy or Not to Buy?

Wearing ÉCLAT 972 VIP is like listening to a cover band attempting a complex song. You recognize the tune, but the musicianship isn't quite there. It delivers a similar olfactory impression, but the refinement and the smoother blending are clearly missing. What you gain is a fragrance that shouts its presence. What you lose is the subtlety and sophistication of the original composition. It's a loud declaration, not a quiet whisper.

Projection Power

This clone has some serious tenacity. I got 8 hours on skin, pushing to 10 on clothes. The projection is also noteworthy; it projects strongly for the first 2-3 hours, easily reaching beyond arm's length. I tested this in an office setting and found it could be overpowering in close quarters, particularly during that initial strong projection phase.