Cassius

The Scent Profile

Cassius opens with a blast of nutmeg and a surprisingly tart green apple. It’s recognizable as a Carlisle imitation, hitting maybe 89% of the mark. The rose in the heart is dialed back compared to Carlisle; it's less floral, more spiced apple pie. The drydown is where the biggest difference appears. Cassius leans heavily into a slightly synthetic vanilla and patchouli mix. Carlisle's base is richer, smoother. This has a rougher, cheaper feel, but that’s expected.

To Buy or Not to Buy?

Cassius offers a decent approximation of Carlisle . Is it a 1:1 dupe? Absolutely not. The synthetic edge is noticeable, especially in the base. However, for those unwilling to shell out big bucks for Parfums de Marly, this is a viable alternative. If you're happy with an 89% similar scent profile and aren't a total snob about ingredients, it’s worth considering. For pure scent enjoyment? Not necessarily.

Projection Power

Longevity is acceptable. I get a solid 6 hours on skin, projecting moderately for the first 2. It becomes a skin scent after about 4 hours. On clothing, it lasts longer, pushing closer to 8 hours. Don't expect beast mode projection. It performs respectably .