
Scentonym Analysis
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
Notes & Nuances
Apple Cognac opens with a spicy cardamom kick, softened by a touch of bergamot. Think warm spices meets a crisp apple cider. As it dries down, you get a boozy heart of rum and brandy, alongside that juicy apple note. It's definitely in the same ballpark as Kilian's Apple Brandy on the Rocks; I'd say it captures around 95% of the original's DNA. Montagne's version leans slightly sweeter in the base, perhaps due to the ambroxan, while the original has a drier, oakier finish. A good attempt, but not a perfect 1:1.
How Long Does it Last?
Longevity is decent point. I get about 5-6 hours on my skin. Projection is moderate; it sits closer to the skin after the initial hour or so. This is not a beast mode fragrance, but it does create a nice scent bubble.
Conclusion
Apple Cognac is a solid choice if you enjoy boozy apple scents and don't want to shell out big bucks for the Kilian. It's a versatile fragrance, perfect for fall evenings, date nights, or even a cozy day at home. The original is undoubtedly smoother and more refined, but If you're on a budget, this is a great way to enjoy a similar vibe without breaking the bank. Someone looking for an affordable, crowd-pleasing fall/winter fragrance should definitely check this out.
Performance Audit
Based on average wear time
Sillage & radius
Relative to market avg
Why we track this:
Price Arbitrage: Significant savings compared to the original Kilian pricing.
Community Verified: Cross-referenced against 68 enthusiast votes for accuracy.
Beast Mode Performance: Identified as having exceptional longevity and projection.