Carnal Gray

Notes & Nuances

Carnal Gray opens with a respectable interpretation of Gris Charnel’s signature cardamom and fig accord. The black tea is present, though slightly more astringent here, giving it a sharper initial impact. The heart reveals a powdery iris note, similar to the original, but the bourbon vetiver leans a bit greener and less creamy. The base develops into a sandalwood and tonka bean combination that is fairly faithful. However, it lacks the smooth, luxurious depth found in BDK's blend. The overall composition is about 95% similar; the main difference lies in the quality of the raw materials. Carnal Gray has a slightly synthetic edge, particularly noticeable in the drydown where the tonka bean feels less refined.

The Verdict

Carnal Gray is a solid dupe for Gris Charnel. It captures the essence of the original . However, if you are seeking a truly luxurious and deeply nuanced fragrance experience, the original remains superior. Carnal Gray provides a satisfying, cost-effective entry point; those wanting the ultimate experience should still seek out the original.

How Long Does it Last?

Longevity is average. I get around 6 hours on skin, with moderate projection for the first 2 hours. It settles closer to the skin after that. A respectable performance point, but far from beast mode.