Tobacco Noir

The Scent Profile

Tobacco Noir opens with a spicy warmth. Cinnamon and pepper dance, a familiar echo of Herod, but with a slightly rougher edge. The heart unfolds a comforting tobacco leaf, paired with a wisp of incense – think dimly lit library, not cathedral. The osmanthus adds a fruity-leathery undertone, unique to this composition. Where this strays from Herod is in the base. The vanilla is less refined, more blunt. The Iso E Super amps up the woodiness, but feels a bit synthetic, lacking the smooth amber of the original. Overall, it captures about 95% of Herod’s DNA.

The Performance Stats

Longevity is impressive. I get a solid 7-8 hours on skin, projecting moderately for the first two. It sits closer to the skin after that, creating a personal, comforting aura. It's a fragrance bubble, not a room filler.

Is it Worth It?

If Herod whispers sophistication, Tobacco Noir speaks with a slightly louder, less polished voice. The price difference is substantial, and for most, the compromise is worth it. If you crave Herod's vibe without the hefty price tag, Tobacco Noir is a solid choice. If you demand absolute refinement, stick with the original. But for the cost-conscious individual who appreciates a cozy, spicy tobacco fragrance, this delivers.