A La Rose

The Scent Profile

Zimaya's A La Rose attempts to capture the floral intoxication of Kilian's Good Girl Gone Bad, achieving a respectable likeness. The opening bursts with a fruity osmanthus and indolic jasmine, mimicking the original's immediate allure. A powdery May Rose attempts to round out the top, but feels slightly thin compared to the richer nuance of Kilian.

The heart dives into tuberose and narcissus, a signature of the inspiration. However, this is where the separation begins. The tuberose is less creamy, more sharp, exhibiting a detectable synthetic edge not present in the original. The base attempts an amber and cedar grounding, but the amber is simplified, lacking the complex honeyed warmth of Good Girl Gone Bad. Overall, the clone captures approximately 91% of the original's DNA, but lacks the depth and refinement.

The Performance Stats

Longevity is moderate. Expect around 5-6 hours of noticeable presence. Projection is initially strong, filling a room for the first hour before settling closer to the skin. The scent bubble remains detectable for about 3 hours. It's a decent clone, especially but the synthetic facets are undeniable. However, for casual wear or as a gateway to explore the white floral genre, this is a worthwhile option. For someone new to the fragrance game, and not wanting to spend hundreds on a bottle, this is a good option.