
Scentonym Analysis
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
Bottom Line
This composition is best suited for brief, casual engagements, such as running errands or a quick coffee date. Its somewhat dense sweetness might overwhelm in confined spaces or professional settings. While not a faithful recreation, it offers a straightforward, albeit simplified, rose fragrance suitable for those seeking a prominent floral presence in cooler weather.
First Impressions & Dry Down
Roses D'Emotion opens with a dominant Turkey red rose note, but the pink pepper asserts itself too strongly, creating a slightly medicinal camphoraceous effect, reminiscent of cherry cough syrup rather than a refined spice. The heart attempts to replicate the raspberry bloom, but exhibits a slightly candied artificiality which is not unpleasant but steers away from the naturalistic intent of its muse. Where the original offers a transparent, airy rose, this leans heavier, slightly cloying. The base attempts papyrus, but the amber used here is heavy-handed. It manifests as an unctuous, slightly plasticky warmth, lacking the dryness and paper-like quality anticipated. The drydown is noticeably less sophisticated, lacking the nuanced layers and evolving complexity.
Longevity & Projection
On my skin, Roses D'Emotion lasts approximately 5-6 hours, with projection extending to about one arm's length for the first hour, quickly retracting to a skin scent thereafter. Tested in both indoor, climate-controlled environments and during a moderate outdoor walk, the performance remains consistent, though the synthetic edge becomes more apparent with increased heat.
Performance Audit
Based on average wear time
Sillage & radius
Relative to market avg
Why we track this:
Price Arbitrage: Significant savings compared to the original Byredo pricing.
Community Verified: Cross-referenced against 170 enthusiast votes for accuracy.