Tobacco Rose

Scent Breakdown

Rogue Perfumery’s Tobacco Rose aims for BDK's Tabac Rose, and it gets respectably close. The opening presents a juicy plum and a noticeable pink pepper zing, a touch sharper than BDK's smoother start. The heart leans heavily into a dark chocolate rose, a nice touch. There’s cinnamon in there, lending a spicy warmth. However, the rose here feels slightly less refined, with a hint of synthetic edge, a common trait in budget clones. The drydown reveals tobacco and patchouli, providing a solid, grounding base. I'd say it captures about 90% of the original's DNA. It's recognizable, but not a perfect match.

Performance Reality Check

Longevity is decent. I got around 6 hours on my skin, which is reasonable point. Projection is moderate; it creates a nice scent bubble without being overpowering. It won't fill a room, which might be a plus for some.

Bottom Line

For those seeking the *idea* of Tabac Rose without the hefty price tag, Rogue Perfumery’s Tobacco Rose is a worthy contender. Yes, it lacks some of the finesse and natural quality of the original. The rose has a slight "shampoo" quality to it in direct comparison. But considering the price difference (BDK is easily 10x more), this is a sensible alternative. If you need the absolute best and money is no object, stick with BDK. But if you're a value-conscious fragrance lover who enjoys rose-tobacco blends, this is a solid gamble.