Good Girl Clones

"### First Impressions & Dry Down Ishraq Gold opens with an almond accord that leans more marzipan than raw almond. The coffee note is present, but muted compared to Good Girl; a slightly synthetic roasted aroma. The heart attempts to replicate the tuberose-jasmine-orange blossom trifecta, but the tuberose feels simplified, lacking the creamy richness found in the original. Orange blossom is more prominent here. The base provides a tonka bean and vanilla sweetness. A cocoa note is present, adding depth. Overall, Ishraq Gold captures approximately 89% of Good Girl's DNA. Where it falters is in the quality of the ingredients; the notes feel less nuanced, slightly sharper. ### Longevity & Projection Longevity is moderate, clocking in at around 5-6 hours on skin. Projection is initially strong for the first hour, creating a noticeable scent bubble, then quickly settling closer to the skin. Respraying is advisable for all-day wear. ### Conclusion Ishraq Gold is a respectable budget option for those seeking the Good Girl experience without the designer price tag. The slightly synthetic edge and simplified floral accord are trade-offs point. If you demand hyper-realistic and nuanced floral notes, stick with the original. However, for casual wear, or for someone new to fragrance, Ishraq Gold offers a decent approximation . Good Girl is undoubtedly more refined, but the tenfold price increase might not justify the difference for all consumers."

"### First Impressions & Dry Down Rawaa opens with a candied almond, a sugary rush, more Jolly Rancher than Marzipan. The coffee note is dialed down, a whisper compared to Good Girl's bolder brew. Quickly, the white florals surface. It's a decent tuberose, a touch synthetic, but serviceable. Jasmine and orange blossom add lift, preventing the almond from becoming cloying. The dry down is where Rawaa cleaves closest to its inspiration: tonka bean, vanilla, and cacao create a warm, comforting base. However, the cacao lacks the original's depth, leaning towards powdered cocoa mix. Overall, it mimics the vibe of Good Girl at about 88%. Less polished, certainly, but recognizable. ### Performance Reality Check Longevity is moderate; expect around 5-6 hours. Projection is arms-length for the first hour, then it settles into a skin scent. It's not a beast mode performer, but it does its job. ### The Verdict Rawaa is for the woman who enjoys the playful, confident energy of Good Girl but doesn't want to drop a fortune. It's a more youthful take, ditching some of the original's sophistication for a sweeter, simpler profile. A safe blind buy if you already enjoy the Carolina Herrera scent."

"### Conclusion Shaghaf Pour Femme is a solid buy It scratches that itch without breaking the bank. Is it as luxurious as the original? No. Does it smell good and last a decent amount of time? Absolutely. If you're okay with a slightly less refined version, this is a great daily driver. If you demand perfection and the highest quality ingredients, stick with Carolina Herrera. Otherwise, save your cash and enjoy. ### Scent Breakdown Shaghaf Pour Femme definitely channels Good Girl. I'd put it at maybe 92% similar. The opening hits you with that familiar blast of almond and coffee, though the almond is slightly more prominent here, a touch sweeter. The heart of tuberose and jasmine is where it deviates a bit. It’s not quite as creamy or nuanced as the original; there's a slightly sharper floral edge. The drydown is cozy – tonka, cacao, and vanilla create a warm, inviting base. But again, the cacao feels a bit more synthetic, lacking the depth of the real deal. It's a good imitation, but not perfect. ### Performance Reality Check Longevity is surprisingly good . I get a solid 6-7 hours, which is respectable. Projection is moderate for the first 2 hours, then it settles closer to the skin. It's noticeable without being overpowering. Perfect for the office or a date night where you want to be noticed, but not announce your arrival from across the room."

"### How it Smells Bit Hooran opens with a blast of almond and roasted coffee. The almond note, while present, leans synthetic – a slightly bitter marzipan rather than natural almond extract. Coffee accord is there, but lacks the nuanced bitterness and depth found in Good Girl. Heart notes emerge quickly: a blend of tuberose, jasmine sambac, and orange blossom. The white floral bouquet attempts to mimic Good Girl's creamy core, but feels less refined, more muddled. Drydown reveals the tonka bean, cacao, and vanilla. This base is where Bit Hooran veers farthest from the original. The cacao is faint, overshadowed by a sweet, slightly powdery vanilla. Overall, I'd estimate this hits around 92% similarity. The key difference lies in the quality of ingredients – the original boasts a smoothness and depth absent here. ### Bottom Line Bit Hooran is a serviceable clone . It captures the essence of Good Girl without replicating the sophistication. If you crave the DNA of Good Girl on a budget and are not overly sensitive to synthetic notes, this is a viable option. However, for those seeking the full complexity and luxurious feel of Carolina Herrera's original, the significant price difference is justified. The original is a smoother, more refined experience. This offers a quick and inexpensive fix. ### Wear time & Sillage Longevity is surprisingly decent. I got around 6 hours on skin. Projection is moderate for the first hour, then settles closer to the skin. This is not a room-filler. Respraying is necessary to maintain the initial impact."

"### Scent Breakdown Pride of Armaf Women aims for that Good Girl aura. The opening delivers a similar almond-coffee jolt. It's not as smoothly blended, though. A slightly screechy synthetic vibe lingers. The tuberose and jasmine heart attempts to mirror the original's creamy floral sweetness, but it lacks the same luxurious depth. The drydown presents a comforting tonka, cacao, and vanilla blend. It's sweeter, more gourmand-leaning than Good Girl's darker, woodier base. Think 90% similar in overall impression. The differences are mostly in ingredient quality. ### Final Thoughts This is for the woman who appreciates the Good Girl vibe but doesn't want to spend a fortune. It's a fun, flirty fragrance for nights out. The synthetic edges are noticeable up close, but from a distance, it captures the essence of the original. If you value ingredient quality and nuanced blending, stick with Carolina Herrera. However, if you want an affordable dupe for everyday wear, Pride of Armaf Women is a solid option. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is decent. I got around 6 hours on skin with moderate projection for the first 2. Then it settles closer, becoming a sweet skin scent. Not a beast, but perfectly acceptable ."

"### The Scent Profile Qimmah for Women opens with an immediate blast of almond and robust coffee. The almond leans slightly synthetic, lacking the nuanced marzipan quality of higher-end compositions. The coffee note, however, is a decent rendition – dark and slightly bitter, offering a counterpoint to the initial sweetness. Transitioning to the heart, tuberose takes center stage, supported by jasmine sambac and a touch of orange blossom. The floral accord is recognizable as an interpretation of Good Girl, but it lacks the creamy smoothness and refined character. The drydown introduces tonka bean, cacao, and vanilla, creating a gourmand base. This phase is where the clone diverges most noticeably; the cacao feels powdery and less rich, and the vanilla lacks the depth and complexity found in the original. Overall, it captures approximately 88% of Good Girl's DNA. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is moderate. I get about 5-6 hours on skin, with projection initially strong for the first hour, then settling into a closer skin scent. Sillage is present, but not overpowering. However, be aware of the synthetic edges and the slight deviations from the original's luxurious feel. For someone seeking a refined and high-quality experience, investing in the genuine article is still warranted. But, for a casual, everyday wear, Qimmah performs adequately."

"### To Buy or Not to Buy? Look, it's a clone. A pretty good one, but still a clone. It captures the essence without completely nailing the nuances. If you appreciate high-quality ingredients and a smoother blend, yes. But if you just want that recognizable Good Girl vibe on a budget? This will do the trick. It’s a great daily driver when you don’t want to use your expensive bottles. ### How it Smells Classy Chic Girl comes on strong! That almond and coffee opening is instantly recognizable as a Good Girl dupe. It’s maybe 81% there. You get that sweet, slightly roasted vibe, but this one has a sharper edge, probably due to cheaper synthetics. The heart follows pretty faithfully with the tuberose and jasmine shining through, though again, a bit less rounded than the original. The dry down is where it diverges most. The cacao and tonka are present, but the vanilla seems amped up, creating a sweeter, almost cloying finish if you overspray. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is surprisingly decent. I get a solid 6-7 hours on my skin. Projection is moderate for the first two hours, then it settles closer to the skin. It's office-appropriate if you go light on the trigger. Two sprays max. Any more, and you risk being *that* person."

"### First Impressions & Dry Down B.A.D Femme is Maison Alhambra's take on Carolina Herrera's Good Girl. The opening blast hits you with a strong almond and coffee accord, but it's not quite as smooth or refined as the original. There's a slightly sharper, more synthetic edge here. The heart attempts the tuberose-jasmine dance, but it's a little louder, less blended. Orange blossom adds a touch of sweetness. The drydown is where it gets closer to the original. The tonka bean, cacao, and vanilla create a warm, gourmand base. I'd say it's about 89% similar, missing some of the sophisticated nuances of Good Girl. ### Longevity & Projection Performance is decent, especially considering the price. Expect around 5-6 hours of noticeable wear. Projection is moderate for the first hour or two, then it settles closer to the skin. It won't fill a room, but people nearby will smell it. ### The Verdict For the budget-conscious, B.A.D Femme is a solid option. It captures the essence of Good Girl without breaking the bank. Is it a perfect dupe? No. Does it smell good? Yes. If you can't justify the price tag of the original, and you're okay with a *slightly* less polished version, this is a worthy contender. Just don't expect niche quality at discounter prices. A good choice for casual wear and a sweet-smelling steal."

"### Olfactory Experience Le Style Blush by Zoghbi aims for the Good Girl DNA, and lands somewhere around 85% similar. The opening has that familiar almond-coffee blast, though a bit sharper, a touch more synthetic than Carolina Herrera's version. The heart of tuberose and jasmine is present, though less creamy and more...linear. It lacks the smooth blending found in the original. The drydown features tonka bean and vanilla, but the cacao feels more like a generic chocolate accord. It's a good attempt, but the difference is noticeable, especially if you're familiar with the original. ### The Verdict Le Style Blush is a solid option. If you want a close approximation of Good Girl without breaking the bank, this is a worthwhile contender. The synthetic edge is there, but not overpowering. Buy it if you want the vibe, not the brand. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is surprisingly decent. I get about 5-6 hours on my skin, which is respectable . Projection is moderate for the first hour, then sits closer to the skin. Don't expect beast mode performance here. It's a subtle, everyday scent."

"### Is it Worth It? For the budget-conscious, Z38 is a decent substitute. It's not a perfect dupe, and the synthetic undertones are noticeable if you're familiar with Good Girl. However, if you crave that sweet, floral gourmand profile without dropping serious cash, this is a viable option. If you want the real deal and can afford it, go for it. But for everyday wear, Z38 scratches the itch without breaking the bank. A solid choice for those who prioritize affordability. ### First Impressions & Dry Down Z38 attempts a faithful recreation of Good Girl, and comes respectably close. The opening hits you with that familiar sweet almond and coffee combo, though it lacks the smooth refinement of the original. There's a slightly synthetic edge, particularly in the initial blast. The heart blooms into a tuberose and jasmine blend, again, a touch rougher than the Carolina Herrera version. The drydown leans heavily on tonka bean and vanilla, providing a warm, gourmand finish that's comforting, even if the cacao is rather muted. I'd say it captures about 85% of Good Girl's DNA. ### Projection Power Don't expect beast mode performance. Z38 projects moderately for the first hour or two, then settles closer to the skin. I got about 5-6 hours of noticeable wear. It's acceptable point, but requires reapplication if you want it to last all day."