Target Profile
I Clones
We found 38 verified alternatives for Widian's I. Compare performance, accuracy, and price below.
Wurood Bois D'Arabie
Fragrance World
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Scent Breakdown Wurood Bois D'Arabie initiates with a sharply citric introduction, the mandarin and grapefruit vying for dominance, underpinned by a raspy pink pepper. However, the citrus possesses a cleaning-product harshness, lacking the nuanced zest of natural oils. The heart attempts to evoke richness, the incense presenting as an ashy, almost extinguished ember, while the tobacco note translates as a saccharine, dried-fruit compote. The saffron adds a metallic tang, discordant rather than harmonious. As it settles, the oud emerges, though it's a thin, bordering-on-medicinal rendition – closer to band-aids than aged wood. The leather is rendered as synthetic vinyl, and the amber possesses an oddly plasticky finish, leaving a slightly acrid trail. It diverges significantly from its inspiration, missing the original's velvety depth. ### The Performance Stats Longevity sits around six hours, with projection extending just beyond arm's length for the first hour, quickly retracting to a skin scent thereafter. Tested indoors under controlled climate, it proved fleeting and underwhelming. ### Is it Worth It? Wearing Wurood Bois D'Arabie instead of the original I by Widian yields a simplified, somewhat distorted interpretation. While it captures a vague semblance of the intended olfactory direction, it sacrifices the plush textures and intricate development of the source material. What's gained is merely a hint of the desired aroma; what's lost is the complexity and refined elegance that defines the genuine article."
Emotions N°01 Vetiver Pamplemousse
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Notes & Nuances Zara's Emotions N°01 Vetiver Pamplemousse starts with a surprisingly tart grapefruit – almost aggressively citrusy, like concentrated juice – softened by a touch of sweet mandarin. The pink pepper is there, adding a whisper of spice. It diverges from the inspiration pretty quickly as the incense note comes across quite harsh, almost medicinal, contrasting heavily with the brighter opening. The tobacco and saffron are present, but sit further back, never quite fully developing. The base is a muddled mix of something vaguely oudy, a hint of smoky leather, and a sweet amber that borders on cloying. In the drydown, that medicinal incense persists far too long, becoming somewhat tiring. It never achieves the smooth, blended character of the inspiration. ### Bottom Line Wearing Emotions N°01 Vetiver Pamplemousse, you gain a bright, citrus-forward opening that's pleasant enough. You lose the refined complexity and sophisticated blending of the inspiration. Where the original feels like a carefully curated experience, this leans more towards a straightforward, linear scent. This works in a pinch, and might satisfy those looking for a basic citrus and smoky fragrance, but it lacks the unique elegance of the Widian. ### Wear time & Sillage I get about 5 hours of solid wear from this one. Projection is moderate, extending to about an arm's length for the first hour or two, then settling closer to the skin. I wore it during a workday at the office. It didn't offend, but it also didn't wow. I also tested it at an outdoor restaurant, and it faded quickly in the open air."
Azul Noche
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Notes & Nuances Azul Noche opens with a promising burst of tangy mandarin, quickly overtaken by a biting pink pepper that feels somewhat forced. The grapefruit adds a sourness, rather than a juicy sweetness. This is where the resemblance to Widian's I begins to fade. The heart introduces a smoky incense accord, but it’s muddled and lacks the refined character of the original. The tobacco note leans towards a dry, ashy quality, almost stale cigarette. The saffron attempts to add warmth, but only contributes a metallic tang. The drydown reveals a slightly synthetic oud, paired with a plasticky leather note that feels thin and somewhat disappointing. The amber is there, providing a vague sweetness. It diverges quite a bit; it is a completely different fragrance. ### Performance Reality Check Longevity is moderate, lasting about 5-6 hours on my skin. Projection is initially strong, extending about an arm's length for the first hour, then quickly settles closer to the skin. I tested it in a closed office environment. It does not cut through at all, and the fragrance fades rather quickly. ### The Verdict This fragrance is suitable for casual situations where close encounters aren't expected. I'd recommend it for running quick errands, or perhaps a very laid-back brunch with friends who won't be close enough to scrutinize the nuances. It's not something I'd wear on a date, or to an important business meeting. It's just too simple to be considered a power player."
Summer Collection Zara
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### The Scent Profile Summer Collection Zara opens with a blast of candied grapefruit and a slight pink peppercorn tingle. It lacks the nuance of the inspiration, leaning into a simpler citrus profile; it's more akin to grapefruit soda than the full complexity of fresh fruit. The heart brings forth a sweet, almost medicinal incense accord mixed with dry, unlit pipe tobacco. There is a saffron note here, but it pulls plasticky. The drydown is where this diverges most noticeably from the original. The oud is present, but it's a thin, synthetic oud with a prominent Iso E Super woody amber note. The leather is vaguely there, more like a vinyl car seat than supple leather. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is moderate; I get around 5-6 hours on skin, with the projection being noticeable within arm's reach for the first hour, then settling closer to the skin. I wore it during a casual lunch outing and found it suitable, but it faded quickly in the summer heat. ### Final Thoughts This is best suited for cooler spring or autumn days, for casual wear or running errands. The sweetness makes it better for daytime than evenings. It works in an office environment where strong fragrances are discouraged."
Amber Vanilla
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Olfactory Experience Zara's Amber Vanilla launches with a juicy burst of mandarin and grapefruit, immediately tempered by a rough pink pepper. This opening is brash compared to I by Widian's smoother citrus introduction. The heart unfolds with a smoky incense note—reminiscent of a newly extinguished candle—mingling with the sweeter tones of tobacco and a medicinal saffron. The tobacco leans toward pipe tobacco, but without the sweetness. It deviates noticeably from the original's more nuanced spicy profile. The drydown is where the largest divergence occurs. The Zara exhibits a plasticky oud accord, alongside a straightforward leather and amber blend. This combination creates a cloying sweetness, with a synthetic amber edge, unlike the more refined, resinous amber in Widian. ### Is it Worth It? This scent is best suited for the cooler months, specifically autumn evenings. It works well for casual settings like a coffee date or a relaxed dinner. The sweetness might be too much for warmer weather. I’d also avoid wearing this in more formal environments. ### The Performance Stats I get about 5-6 hours of longevity with this fragrance. Projection is moderate for the first hour, reaching about an arm's length, then it settles closer to the skin. I wore this during a casual weekend outing and found it faded quite quickly in the cooler air. Indoors, it performed slightly better, but never became overpowering."
Cerise Peonies
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### First Impressions & Dry Down Cerise Peonies throws a lot at you right up front. That mandarin and grapefruit are fleeting – more like the memory of citrus zest than actual fruit. Quickly, a medicinal cherry note emerges, think cough syrup with a distinct spicy kick from the pink pepper. The heart is where it deviates from its muse; less refined. The incense is present, but muddled with a harsh tobacco accord – like opening an old ashtray. The saffron, instead of adding that leathery nuance, amplifies the peppery sharpness. As it dries, the oud is undeniably there, though synthetic and screechy, sitting atop a base of slightly plasticky amber and something vaguely resembling worn leather. The drydown lacks the smooth integration of the inspiration. ### Is it Worth It? If Cerise Peonies was a movie character, it'd be the try-hard villain in a direct-to-video action flick – all the menacing posturing but lacking the depth and conviction of the real thing. ### Longevity & Projection I got a solid 5 hours out of Cerise Peonies. The first hour projects strongly, easily filling a room, but then quickly settles to about an arm's length. I wore it to a casual Friday at the office; it was noticed, but I wouldn't recommend it for close encounters. Also tested it during a light workout – the synthetic notes intensified with heat, not a pleasant experience."
Fields at Nightfall
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### How it Smells Fields at Nightfall opens with a jarring collision of notes. The mandarin and grapefruit, while listed, present with a harsh, almost cleaning-product astringency, veering into lemon floor cleaner territory. The pink pepper attempts to inject a needed spark, but instead adds a grating, sinus-clearing sharpness, not found in the smoother inspiration. The heart struggles to coalesce. The incense note is a vague, ashy whisper, rather than a rich, resinous presence. The tobacco accord lacks depth, coming across as dried, shredded paper with a hint of stale cigarette smoke. Saffron is noticeable, yet muted, lending a metallic tang that feels disconnected from the other elements. The drydown fares slightly better. The oud is a synthetic approximation – more like pencil shavings than true agarwood. The leather is a vinyl-esque, plasticky approximation, and the amber, while present, smells of cloying, sweet, artificial vanilla, detracting from the expected warmth and depth. This clone fails to capture the nuance of the original, presenting a simplified, and unfortunately, synthetic facsimile. ### Bottom Line If this scent were a character in a movie, it would be an understudy forced to perform a role they are woefully unprepared for – technically present, but lacking the artistry and depth to truly convince. ### Longevity & Projection Longevity is surprisingly robust, clocking in at around 7 hours. Projection is moderate for the first hour, reaching about an arm’s length, before settling closer to the skin for the duration. Tested indoors in a climate-controlled office."
Wurood Blanc Sapphire
Fragrance World
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### First Impressions & Dry Down Wurood Blanc Sapphire kicks off with a fizzy mandarin note battling a slightly bitter grapefruit rind. The pink peppercorn is dialed up high here, creating a sharper, almost medicinal edge compared to the smoother opening of Widian's "I". The heart dives straight into a smoky incense, thankfully avoiding the potpourri vibe some cheaper incense accords can give. The tobacco is present, but as dried leaf rather than sweet pipe tobacco. Saffron adds a leathery bitterness, differentiating it slightly from the original's more blended heart. The drydown features a slightly synthetic oud note, paired with a smooth, albeit a bit plasticky, amber and a restrained leather. It's a competent interpretation, but the opening and drydown reveal where some corners were cut. ### Final Thoughts This is a good daily driver for cooler weather when you want something with a touch of sophistication without being overly formal. It could work for date night, but be mindful of the slightly synthetic drydown. It thrives in situations where you want to project confidence and a hint of mystery. ### The Performance Stats I get about 6-7 hours of wear from Wurood Blanc Sapphire. Projection is solid for the first two hours, extending about an arm's length. After that, it settles into a more intimate scent bubble. I've worn this to the office on cooler days and to casual evening outings."
Evening Maiden Orchid
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Olfactory Experience Evening Maiden Orchid opens with a sharply delineated mandarin and grapefruit accord. The pink peppercorn attempts to add lift, but registers instead as a slightly acrid, almost metallic tang. It lacks the nuanced vibrancy present in *I*. The heart leans heavily into a dry, ashy incense. The tobacco note presents as unlit pipe tobacco, dusty and papery, lacking any sweetness or warmth. The saffron is muted, contributing only a slight leathery nuance rather than its characteristic golden hue. The base is where the divergence is most pronounced. The oud accord is thin and synthetic, possessing a noticeable rubbery edge. The leather accord is similarly artificial, recalling vinyl car seats in intense sun. The amber attempts to soften this, but results in a plasticky drydown. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is moderate, clocking in around 5-6 hours. Projection is initially strong, extending one to two arm lengths for the first hour, but rapidly diminishes to a skin scent. Tested in indoor office and outdoor casual settings. ### Conclusion This composition, with its ashy incense and rubbery oud, is best suited for cooler weather, specifically late fall and early winter. The fragrance lends itself to evening events, but the synthetic elements might make it more appropriate for informal gatherings rather than sophisticated affairs."
Regal White
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Olfactory Experience Regal White kicks off with a blast of juicy mandarin, quickly overtaken by an acrid pink pepper note that clashes with the grapefruit. It’s a discordant opening; think cleaning supplies trying to mask stale cigarette smoke. The heart attempts to smooth things over with incense, but it’s more of an ashy cardboard than true frankincense. The tobacco is whisper-thin, merely a suggestion of dried leaves. The drydown is where the similarities to I by Widian fade into a distant memory. Gone is the nuanced oud; instead, we are left with a synthetic leather accord reminiscent of cheap car upholstery mingled with a cloying amber sweetness. ### The Verdict Regal White is a fall and winter fragrance best suited for casual settings, maybe a quick trip to the grocery store. The harsh opening and synthetic drydown make it hard to recommend for any situation where you want to make a positive impression. ### Wear time & Sillage Longevity is moderate, clocking in at around 5 hours on skin. Projection is initially strong, pushing out past arm's length for the first hour, before settling closer to the body. I wore this to a casual work meeting, and it felt out of place and somewhat overpowering."
Fig
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Notes & Nuances Zara's "Fig" opens with a jarring grapefruit candy sweetness, a far cry from the original's refined citrus. Pink pepper is amped up, lending a nose-tickling sharpness that clashes with the synthetic mandarin. The heart attempts incense, but it manifests as a vaguely smoky bathroom air freshener. Tobacco is present, yet unfortunately resembles cheap pipe tobacco rather than a cured, leathery leaf. The base arrives quickly: oud, but scrubbed clean of all character, leaning towards a medicinal bandage note. The promised leather is a ghost, replaced by a cloying amber that clings like cheap glue. A plasticky element dominates this drydown. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity is surprising, sticking around for 6-7 hours, though mostly as a skin scent after the first hour. Projection is moderate initially, reaching about an arm's length, before quickly receding. Tested in an office setting and found it distracting. ### Conclusion This is an autumn evening fragrance, attempting cozy, but ending up awkwardly out of place. I envision a character who tries too hard to project sophistication, wearing this to a dimly lit cocktail party and feeling profoundly uncomfortable. Best suited for cooler weather and casual environments where subtleties are unlikely to be noticed."
Wurood Boise D'Arabie
Fragrance World
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### The Scent Profile Wurood Boise D'Arabie throws a confusing opening. The promised mandarin and grapefruit translate to a sharp, almost acrid citrus cleaner note, battling against an initial whiff of something vaguely reminiscent of cherry pipe tobacco. The heart fares slightly better; the incense emerges, though it's a rather ashy, unscented candle wax kind of incense. Tobacco is there, but it leans toward dry, dusty tobacco leaves rather than the sweet, warm richness some might expect. The saffron adds a slight metallic tang. The base is where the wheels truly start to wobble. The oud is a synthetic approximation, a thin veneer over a leathery accord that recalls cheap vinyl car seats. The amber struggles to add warmth, instead lending a slightly cloying sweetness that clashes with the overall composition. Where this differs from the inspiration? It's lacking the smoothness and depth of better constructed fragrances. ### The Verdict This is a fragrance best suited for… absolutely no occasion I can imagine. Its confused composition and lackluster execution render it unsuitable for anything beyond testing the limits of your tolerance for disappointing scents. Perhaps a visit to the garage, tinkering with machinery, is the only scenario where this doesn't feel entirely out of place. ### How Long Does it Last? Longevity hovers around 5-6 hours on my skin, with projection that extends to about arm's length for the first hour, then quickly retreating to a skin scent. I tested this during a workday indoors, and found myself wanting to scrub it off by lunchtime."
Stunningly Venice
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Is it Worth It? If Stunningly Venice were a character, it would be that eager understudy, a bit rough around the edges, trying a little too hard to emulate the star, but ultimately delivers a decent performance in its own right. ### Olfactory Experience Stunningly Venice opens with a burst of juicy mandarin and grapefruit, but quickly leans into a medicinal pink pepper accord. It diverges early from its inspiration; the Widian fragrance boasts a smoother transition. Here, the heart barrels in abruptly: a potent incense note clashes a bit with a syrupy tobacco scent, like cherry cough syrup clinging to the back of your throat. The saffron peeks through, adding a metallic tang. The base is where it finds some redemption. The oud is restrained, thankfully avoiding barnyard territory, and settles into a pleasing, albeit slightly plasticky, amber and leather accord. This is where the resemblance strengthens, providing a warm and comforting conclusion, though with a synthetic acetone edge. ### Performance Reality Check I got a solid 6-7 hours of wear out of Stunningly Venice. Projection is moderate; it radiates about an arm's length for the first 2 hours, then sits closer to the skin. I wore it to a casual Friday at the office; it worked well enough, although the opening might be a bit loud for more conservative environments. I also tested it on a chilly evening walk. It performed respectably, cutting through the cold air."
Emotions N°02 Waterlily Tea Dress
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Bottom Line Wearing Emotions N°02 is a shadow of the original experience. The initial blast of citrus fails to capture the vibrancy of I by Widian, leading to a somewhat muddled and ultimately disappointing experience. What is gained is a fleeting resemblance at the opening; what is lost is the sophistication and depth of the original's nuanced composition, replaced by a plasticky and somewhat abrasive imitation. ### First Impressions & Dry Down Emotions N°02 Waterlily Tea Dress opens with a sharp, almost acrid mandarin. The grapefruit note is present, but rendered with a harsh, synthetic bitterness. Pink pepper attempts to add lift, but falls flat, presenting as a generic spice. The heart struggles to reconcile the promised incense with a cloying, cherry-pipe tobacco accord. The saffron is muted, merely a dusty undertone. The drydown reveals a thin, papery oud that lacks depth and complexity. The leather note is more akin to vinyl car seats than supple hide, melding with a sweet, cloying amber that amplifies the synthetic feel. Compared to I by Widian, this composition lacks the nuance and richness of the original. The brighter, more natural citrus notes and smoother transition of the original are absent here, replaced by jarring shifts and a persistent chemical edge. ### Longevity & Projection Longevity is moderate, approximately 5-6 hours on skin. Projection is initially strong, extending about one arm's length for the first hour, then quickly settling into a skin scent. Tested indoors in a climate-controlled environment."
Caviar Bergamot
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### How it Smells Zara's Caviar Bergamot launches with a blast of artificial grapefruit – think concentrated juice box rather than freshly squeezed. The pink pepper tries to add a needed sharpness, but ends up smelling like generic men's shower gel. As it settles, a dusty incense emerges, vaguely reminiscent of church candles left to burn too long. There's a whisper of tobacco, akin to old cigarette ash, not the rich aroma of aged leaves. The base attempts oud, but instead delivers a synthetic wood accord with a plasticky drydown, lacking the complexity of the genuine article. It diverges quite significantly from I by Widian, missing its smoother transitions and nuanced depth. ### Bottom Line If Caviar Bergamot were a movie character, it would be a knock-off superhero – all costume and no actual power. ### Projection Power On my skin, Caviar Bergamot lasts about four hours. Projection is initially strong – a solid arm's length – but it quickly retreats to a skin scent after the first hour. I wore it during a chilly, rainy afternoon while running errands. It didn't evolve; it just faded."
Coastal Salty Forest
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Scent Breakdown Coastal Salty Forest opens with a jarring blast of candied grapefruit – less citrus grove, more artificially flavored soda. The pink pepper attempts to add some spice, but comes across as a fleeting, synthetic sharpness. The heart promises incense and tobacco, but delivers a thin, wispy smoke intertwined with a cloying sweetness reminiscent of cherry cough syrup. It lacks the rich depth and luxurious feel of quality ingredients. In the drydown, the oud is present, though muted, struggling to cut through the synthetic amber and a plasticky leather accord. The overall effect falls short of the salty, oceanic briskness implied by its name. ### To Buy or Not to Buy? This fragrance suits the individual who prioritizes inoffensive, commonplace scents. Someone who enjoys a fleeting sweetness and a hint of something 'exotic' without committing to true complexity. Picture a young professional, perhaps a recent graduate navigating the corporate landscape, seeking a fragrance that blends in rather than stands out. Their personal style leans towards safe and predictable choices, valuing practicality over artistic expression. ### Projection Power Longevity is moderate, clocking in at around 5 hours. Projection is initially strong, radiating within an arm's length for the first hour, then quickly receding into a skin scent. Tested in an office environment, it garnered neither compliments nor complaints – a testament to its unobtrusive nature."
MSK 004/NTL
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### To Buy or Not to Buy? This fragrance would suit someone seeking a boozy, sweet aroma with a slightly challenging edge, perfect for close encounters in dimly lit spaces - like a dive bar on a cold night. It lends itself to a character who enjoys a little drama and wants to project an aura of confident mystery. Best suited for colder months, and only when boldness is the intention. ### The Scent Profile MSK 004/NTL throws you into an immediate sensory collision. The opening is a burst of candied grapefruit peel, less about zesty brightness and more like a sugary shellac. A prickly pink peppercorn note cuts through the initial sweetness, hinting at a more sophisticated journey, though it struggles against a synthetic mandarin note. The heart attempts to blend incense with a syrupy tobacco accord – envision a humidor filled with cherry cough drops – plus a saffron note that reads slightly metallic. The base reveals the cracks: a muted oud, far from the barnyard funk of the real deal, blended with a pleather note that lacks depth, and an amber that leans toward a vanillin sweetness rather than a rich resinous warmth. The original 'I' possesses a smoother blend and richer natural ingredients; here, a certain shrillness persists. ### Longevity & Projection On my skin, MSK 004/NTL lasts about five hours. The projection is moderate, extending roughly an arm's length for the first two hours before settling into a skin scent. I wore it during a brisk autumn walk and found it evaporated quickly in the open air. Similarly, in a heated office environment, it became faint and generic after a few hours."
Boldly Seoul
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Final Thoughts This fragrance is for the individual who prioritizes quantity over quality and doesn't mind sacrificing refinement for a fleeting impression of luxury. Someone who values a grab-and-go option, never demanding the utmost in sillage or sophistication. They’re most likely a student or someone starting their career, exploring different scent profiles, without the budget for high-end niche. ### First Impressions & Dry Down Boldly Seoul opens with a jarring chemical grapefruit note, less fresh citrus and more industrial cleaner. The pink pepper tries to cut through, but it's fighting a losing battle against the initial synthetic blast. In the mid, a medicinal incense emerges, reminiscent of cherry cough syrup, mingling uneasily with a muted tobacco that's closer to pipe ash than cured leaf. The saffron is barely perceptible, a ghost of spice. As it dries down, a leathery accord surfaces, thin and plasticky, accompanied by a vaguely sweet amber and a muted oud. The oud lacks depth and smells more like woody aromachemicals than anything authentic. The scent is not a duplicate, but rather a diluted interpretation that captures facets of the original’s DNA imperfectly. ### Wear time & Sillage Longevity is a middling 5-6 hours on skin, with projection that extends to about an arm's length for the first hour, then quickly fades to a skin scent. Tested in an office setting, it garnered no compliments and only a slight "what's that smell?" from a colleague. In warmer conditions, the opening becomes even more cloying and unpleasant."
Citrus Water
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### The Scent Profile Citrus Water opens with a sharp, almost acrid mandarin rind note. The grapefruit leans heavily artificial, like concentrated juice from a bottle left open too long. Pink pepper is there, providing a fleeting spiciness, but it's muddled by a general chemical tang. The heart introduces a dusty incense; more grey ash than fragrant smoke. The tobacco presents as dried-out pipe tobacco, faintly sweet, but lacking richness. The saffron is minimal, just a hint of metallic bitterness. The base attempts oud, but falls flat, resembling band-aid adhesive instead. The leather is a vague, synthetic suede, while the amber is sticky and cloying. Compared to what it emulates, it lacks the smoother transitions, nuance, and quality materials of the inspiration. It smells like a simplified, slightly harsher interpretation, missing the refined depth. ### The Verdict Citrus Water is suited for casual daytime wear where a strong statement isn't required. It's best suited for situations where you don't want to deplete your premium fragrances; quick trips to the grocery store, or a last minute gym visit. It's functional as a fragrance, though not particularly unique or memorable. ### Projection Power Longevity hovers around 5 hours on skin. Projection is moderate for the first hour, extending about an arm's length, then quickly retracts to a skin scent. Tested in both office and outdoor environments. The initial blast is assertive, but the drydown becomes faint."
Gracefully Madrid
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Scent Breakdown Gracefully Madrid begins with a promising citrus rush, like mandarin oranges left too long in the sun, verging on fermented. The grapefruit note is a fleeting whisper, soon overtaken by an assertive pink pepper that borders on medicinal. The heart introduces a vaguely church-like incense, but the tobacco reads more as dusty hay than cured leaf. A synthetic saffron attempts to add richness but falls flat. The base is where the separation from the inspiration widens. Instead of a nuanced oud, I get a sharp, chemical wood accord. The leather is plasticky, resembling a cheap pleather jacket. The amber is cloying, bordering on sickly sweet, and lacks the depth of true ambergris. ### The Verdict If Gracefully Madrid were a movie character, it would be a used car salesman wearing an imitation designer suit. Looks the part from afar, but up close, the cracks are visible. ### The Performance Stats On my skin, Gracefully Madrid lasts a moderate 5-6 hours. Projection is initially strong, filling a room for the first hour, before settling closer to the skin. I wore it during a cool evening walk and found it performed adequately. It's potent for the first little while, but then it fades quite considerably."
Accord No 3 Woody
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Olfactory Experience Accord No. 3 Woody opens with a promising burst of juicy mandarin tempered by a biting grapefruit rind. The pink pepper adds a prickly heat, not unlike the initial sting of ginger ale. The heart aims for incense and tobacco, but lands closer to sweet cherry pipe tobacco mixed with ash, a far cry from liturgical frankincense. Saffron attempts to add sophistication, but the synthetic edge screams potpourri. The base is where it truly deviates. Instead of a majestic oud and supple leather accord, it presents a plasticky amber cloud. It's reminiscent of a new car interior, but not in a good way. ### Projection Power The initial projection is enthusiastic, filling a room for the first hour. It then retreats to a personal bubble, clinging to skin for around five hours. Tested during a rainy afternoon walk, it felt out of place and characterless. ### Is it Worth It? This is a scent yearning for a grand occasion but dressed in everyday clothes. Best suited for a casual fall evening, a trip to the mall, or perhaps a date where you want to project approachability, not command attention. It's too heavy for summer heat, too simplistic for formal settings, and lacks the gravitas required for winter nights."
Mystery Balance
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### How it Smells Mystery Balance throws a vibrant mandarin and grapefruit cocktail at you, spiked with a cheeky pink pepper bite. It lacks the radiant, natural juiciness of its muse, leaning instead towards a slightly candied sweetness, like mandarin hard candies dissolving on your tongue. The heart introduces a smoky incense and a rough-hewn tobacco accord, thankfully avoiding the cloying cherry cough syrup vibe that cheaper tobacco notes often exhibit. However, the saffron feels muted, a whisper where the original roars. The base presents a tame oud, more of a suggestion than a statement, alongside a supple leather note. The drydown introduces a plasticky edge as it wears on, but that leather accord persists. ### Wear time & Sillage Longevity hovers around 6 hours, projecting confidently within arm's reach for the first two, then settling closer to the skin. Tested during a damp autumn day; it performed admirably during a long walk, maintaining a pleasant aura. ### Bottom Line This is for the individual who enjoys commanding attention with an air of worldly mystery but is a little self-conscious about going overboard. The kind of person who favors dimly lit speakeasies over bustling clubs, wears tailored suits in unconventional fabrics, and keeps a well-worn passport in their pocket. They are drawn to complexity, appreciate the finer things, but don't need to shout about it; instead, let their confidence emanate from within. They may even be a successful architect or an artisan who crafts custom leather goods."
Wonder Rose So Intense
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### First Impressions & Dry Down Wonder Rose So Intense throws a spotlight on a very particular type of charisma. The opening is a vibrant cocktail of pulpy mandarin and grapefruit zest, sharpened by a prickle of pink peppercorns. It's not quite the same as the original; instead of a refined citrus shimmer, it feels more like a candied orange rind dusted with generic spice-rack pepper. The heart attempts to capture the sultry sophistication of incense and tobacco, but falls slightly short. Here, the incense leans towards a smoky crayon wax smell, and the tobacco is more of a generic sweetened pipe tobacco. The saffron is present, but dialed back, lacking the nuanced spice of the inspiration. The drydown introduces oud, amber and leather. The oud offers a subtle woody base, but the leather here feels like vinyl car seats in the summer heat. ### To Buy or Not to Buy? Wearing the original is like attending a dimly lit jazz club in a bespoke suit; this is like recreating the atmosphere with a scented candle and a borrowed fedora. You gain a similar *impression*, but the depth and refinement are noticeably absent. The overall effect is a diluted, slightly synthetic rendering of a complex composition. While not unpleasant, it lacks the gravitas and distinct richness of its inspiration. ### How Long Does it Last? This fragrance lasts about 5-6 hours on my skin. Projection is moderate, reaching about an arm's length for the first two hours before settling closer. I wore it on a chilly evening walk and to an indoor concert; it fared better in the indoor setting where the nuances were more apparent."
Memoire Intense
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### To Buy or Not to Buy? Wearing Memoire Intense versus the original is like opting for a sepia-toned photograph instead of a vibrant oil painting. You get the basic idea, but the depth and richness are undeniably missing. This scent profile creates an aura of studied sophistication, although the synthetic notes undermine any true sense of opulence. It projects the image of someone trying too hard to embody a certain lifestyle, falling slightly short. ### Scent Breakdown Memoire Intense opens with a surprisingly tart grapefruit, but it’s quickly wrestled down by a synthetic mandarin note that smells suspiciously like orange cleaner. The pink pepper attempts to add intrigue, but it can't distract from the initial chemical blast. The heart reveals a dusty, slightly sweet incense, reminiscent of aged paper in a neglected library. The tobacco is muted, more pipe tobacco pouch than smoldering leaf. The saffron presents as an artificial leather accord, with a plasticky undercurrent. The dry down is where this diverges most from its inspiration. The oud is a whisper, overshadowed by an overly sweet, amber accord and a persistent, acrid edge to the leather. ### How Long Does it Last? On my skin, Memoire Intense lasts for approximately 5 hours, with projection extending about one arm’s length for the first hour before settling into a skin scent. I wore it during a rainy afternoon walk; the damp air seemed to amplify the initial citrus blast but did little to improve the overall experience."
Amber & Fig Cashmere
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### First Impressions & Dry Down Amber & Fig Cashmere blasts off with a sugary orange cleaner note, smoothed over by something akin to canned grapefruit. The initial pink pepper is present, but muted, like peppercorns steeped in warm milk. Moving into the heart, the incense is less smoky than it is resinous, recalling the smell of antique shop wood polish. There's a definite pipe tobacco accord, but it lacks depth and leans slightly acrid. The saffron registers as a metallic tang against the sweet amber. The base is where the divergence from the inspiration is most prominent. Instead of a rich, animalic oud, you get a sanitized, almost medicinal wood note alongside a synthetic leather accord. The drydown has a vaguely plasticky, vanillin sweetness. ### Conclusion This fragrance is best suited for cooler weather, specifically autumn and early winter. It's a daytime scent, leaning towards casual settings like weekend brunches, relaxed dates, or informal office environments. It's probably too sweet and cloying for high heat, and lacks the sophistication for formal events. ### Wear time & Sillage This projects moderately for the first hour, extending to about an arm's length. After that, it settles closer to the skin, becoming a personal scent bubble. Longevity is average, clocking in at around 5-6 hours on my skin, with the base notes lingering longest. I wore this during a brisk autumn walk and a workday in a climate-controlled office."
Bleu Oud
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Scent Breakdown Bleu Oud opens with a bracing, almost astringent wave of mandarin and grapefruit. The citrus leans sharply synthetic, exhibiting a cleaning-solution-like edge. The pink pepper is present but muted, contributing only a slight prickle. As it transitions, the heart introduces an incense accord that is noticeably drier and less nuanced than the inspiration. There's a chalky texture here, almost like crushed aspirin. The tobacco is a phantom note, only suggested by a vague, hay-like aroma. Saffron attempts to add depth but presents as a metallic tang. The drydown leans heavily into a simplified oud note – less animalic barnyard, more cedar wood shavings. The leather is more akin to vinyl car seats than supple hide. The amber offers a cloying sweetness that clashes with the drier elements, lacking the smooth, resinous quality of a well-executed amber. It diverges considerably from the original's intricate balance, opting for simplified, linear construction. ### Final Thoughts Bleu Oud is best suited for casual, daytime wear, perhaps running errands or quick trips outside. Its simplified structure and moderate performance make it suitable for situations where a sophisticated or powerful fragrance would be out of place. ### Performance Reality Check On my skin, Bleu Oud managed approximately 5-6 hours of longevity. Projection initially extended to about an arm's length but quickly subsided to a skin scent within the first hour. I tested it in both an office setting and during an evening walk; performance was consistent, if underwhelming, in both scenarios."
Arctic palace
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### How it Smells Arctic Palace opens with a blast of tart grapefruit and fizzy mandarin, quickly overtaken by a cloying pink pepper. This initial phase smells almost medicinal, like cherry cough syrup trying to mask a burnt electrical fire. The heart attempts sophistication with incense and a muted tobacco note, but the saffron smells synthetic, leaning heavily into a plasticky sweetness. I by Widian aims for opulence; Arctic Palace aims for a passable imitation and falls short. The drydown features a scratchy oud accord paired with a pleather-like leather and an amber that evokes cheap potpourri. It's not unpleasant, but lacks the depth and refinement of its inspiration. Where I has smooth transitions, this has abrupt angles. ### Conclusion If Arctic Palace were a character in a movie, it would be a dollar-store Bond villain – all the bluster and none of the gravitas. ### Projection Power Longevity is decent, clocking in at around 6 hours on my skin. Projection is initially strong, filling a small room for the first hour, before quickly settling to a skin scent within two arm lengths. I tested it in a moderately heated office environment. It won't choke anyone out, but be prepared for a strong opening."
Noir Oud
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Olfactory Experience Noir Oud opens with a citrus accord dominated by mandarin, but unfortunately, the grapefruit veers towards a pithy, slightly bitter chemical note, a deviation from the smoother radiance expected. The pink pepper is present, adding a needed prickle, but fails to fully integrate. The heart reveals a clash: the incense is a dry, woody ash, almost like extinguished charcoal, while the tobacco presents as a sweet pipe tobacco extract, lacking nuance. The saffron provides a metallic tang but the three don’t harmonize as they should. The base presents a muddled accord. The oud is a prominent woody aroma, but lacks depth. It sits atop a leather that smells like a new car interior, and the amber possesses a syrupy sweetness that borders on cloying. It lacks the sophisticated development of its inspiration. ### Projection Power Longevity hovers around 6-7 hours on skin. Projection is initially strong, reaching about an arm's length for the first hour, before settling closer to the skin. I tested this in a controlled indoor environment (office) and a more humid outdoor setting, with minimal difference in performance. ### Is it Worth It? Wearing Noir Oud offers a semblance of the original's intended complexity, but the execution falls short. One gains a similar opening salvo of notes, but loses the nuanced transitions and refined ingredients. The overall effect is a flattened, less articulate expression. The synthetic edges and somewhat linear development prevent it from reaching the sophisticated experience found elsewhere."
Oud Verde
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### The Scent Profile Oud Verde initiates with a vigorous citrus accord. The mandarin is pithy, almost fermented, while the grapefruit leans towards its sharper, more acidic rind. Pink pepper presents as a mere prickle rather than a sustained heat. This deviates considerably from the original, where the citrus offers a sweeter, more polished demeanor. The heart introduces a subdued incense, almost ghostly in its presence, failing to fully replicate the robust smokiness found in I by Widian. The tobacco note is reminiscent of dried, unsweetened pipe tobacco rather than the richer, honeyed variety. Saffron imparts a metallic tinge. The base attempts an oud accord, but the synthetic approximation smells like band-aids. The leather is a stiff, cardboard-like imitation. Amber provides a saccharine, cloying sweetness that clashes with the intended complexity. ### The Performance Stats Longevity clocks in at roughly 6 hours on skin, with projection extending to about one arm's length for the initial 2 hours, settling into a skin scent thereafter. Tested in both indoor and outdoor environments; performance remains consistent. ### Final Thoughts Oud Verde best suits casual daytime wear during cooler months. Its synthetic oud and cloying sweetness detract from formal settings, making it better suited for relaxed environments where its shortcomings are less noticeable."
The Golden Lullaby
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### The Scent Profile The Golden Lullaby opens with a surprisingly tart mandarin, quickly overtaken by a sharp, almost acrid grapefruit rind. Pink pepper is present, but muted, lending a slight metallic zing rather than spice. The heart attempts incense, but lands closer to a medicinal guaiac wood, thick and almost cough syrup-like. Tobacco is suggested but is merely a phantom; saffron presents as a synthetic, plasticky sweetness rather than anything natural. The base attempts oud, but registers as a chemical approximation, with a harsh, synthetic edge, coupled with a discordant, vinyl-like leather and a cloying amber that veers into sickly sweet territory. It diverges significantly from the source material. ### Is it Worth It? Wearing the original is akin to experiencing a precisely orchestrated composition; wearing The Golden Lullaby is akin to listening to a poorly recorded cover version. One gains only a superficial resemblance, and sacrifices refinement and depth. The result is a fragrance that mimics aspects of the inspiration, but ultimately lacks its sophistication and nuanced complexity, presenting a harsher, more synthetic experience. ### Wear time & Sillage Longevity is moderate, projecting for roughly 5 hours before fading to a skin scent. Projection is initially strong, extending about an arm's length, but quickly diminishes after the first hour. Tested indoors in a climate-controlled environment."
White
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### To Buy or Not to Buy? If this scent were a character in a movie, it would be a washed-up extra desperately trying to portray a refined aristocrat but failing miserably due to an unfortunate wardrobe and overly eager acting. ### How it Smells White opens with a tart grapefruit, like the peel candied then abandoned. Pink pepper's playful spice is quickly subdued by a heavy, almost medicinal saffron. The heart strives for grandeur, but the incense smells like potpourri left too long in the sun, clashing with a tobacco note that leans more toward stale cigarette ash than pipe tobacco. The oud in the base is timid, overpowered by a plasticky leather accord and an amber that lacks depth, settling into a powdery, vaguely unpleasant sweetness reminiscent of cheap vanilla-scented car air freshener. It diverges from the inspiration with a notable absence of the original's elegant smokiness and sophistication. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is approximately 5 hours, becoming a skin scent by the 3-hour mark. Projection is moderate for the first hour, extending just beyond arm's length before retreating. Tested in an office setting and received no positive comments, only a questioning glance from a colleague."
Paris
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### The Scent Profile Paris opens with a jarring, almost acrid citrus blast - imagine grapefruit rind steeped in cheap vodka. The pink pepper attempts to add a sparkle, but it comes across as more of an aggressive scratch. The heart is where it tries to mimic I by Widian, aiming for that smoky incense, but it lands closer to a burnt rubber accord with a cloying sweetness reminiscent of cherry cough syrup. There's a vague tobacco presence, buried beneath the syrupy haze. The drydown leans heavily into a synthetic oud and a plasticky leather, leaving a trail of amber that smells suspiciously like stale candy. It misses the nuance of the original's refined incense and smooth leather. ### Projection Power Longevity is surprisingly tenacious, clinging to skin for around 6-7 hours, though it becomes a skin scent after the initial two hours. Projection is initially strong, pushing out a good arm's length, but quickly diminishes to a close bubble. I tested it during a chilly evening walk; it cut through the cold, but the synthetic edge became even more pronounced. ### Final Thoughts If this scent were a character in a movie, it would be the try-hard villain who wants to be menacing but ends up tripping over their own feet."
Promise Exclusif
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Scent Breakdown Promise Exclusif opens with a sharp, almost acrid blast of mandarin peel alongside a grapefruit note rendered as something closer to its pith – intensely bitter and devoid of sweetness. The pink peppercorn is present, but subdued, contributing a slight prickle rather than genuine spice. The heart introduces a smoky incense accord, however, it lacks the ecclesiastical depth of high-quality frankincense, leaning toward a cheaper, almost barbecue-like smokiness. The tobacco note is similarly synthetic, more akin to a cherry pipe tobacco aroma than natural leaf. Saffron appears as a metallic tang, rather than the warm, leathery spice it should be. The drydown presents an oud which is predictably synthetic, bearing a faint resemblance to barnyard nuances with an undercurrent of cedar chips. The leather accord is restrained, and the amber provides a vaguely sweet base, though with an underlying plasticky quality. Compared to the inspiration, it misses the refined, multi-layered interplay between notes, opting for a blunt, somewhat linear composition. ### Conclusion Wearing Promise Exclusif provides a simplified and less sophisticated version of the intended scent profile. While it captures some of the general essence, the absence of genuine depth and the reliance on synthetic approximations diminish the overall experience. What's gained is a fleeting familiarity; what's lost is the nuanced complexity and refined character. ### Projection Power On my skin, Promise Exclusif manages about 6-7 hours of wear. Projection is moderate, extending about one arm's length for the first hour, then quickly receding to a skin scent. Tested in both an office environment and outdoors; it performs similarly, with the initial harshness softening slightly over time."
Le Petit Lullaby
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### First Impressions & Dry Down Le Petit Lullaby opens with a burst of candied grapefruit, more akin to a sticky marmalade than fresh fruit. A whisper of pink pepper attempts to cut through the sweetness, but ultimately fails, adding only a fleeting tickle. The heart introduces a smoldering incense note, reminiscent of extinguished birthday candles; unfortunately the tobacco is missing in action. The saffron peeks through as a medicinal tang, like antiseptic gauze. The drydown is where this diverges from its inspiration. The oud is present, but neutered; rather than a complex, woody depth, it presents as a synthetic, sharp amber accord. The leather emerges as a vinyl car seat left baking in the summer sun, lending a slightly plasticky, uncomfortable finish. ### The Verdict This fragrance is best suited for cool autumn evenings, perhaps at an outdoor bonfire where the synthetic edge might be softened by the crisp air. It projects a sense of playful confidence initially, but that confidence fades as the drydown exposes a less refined character. Wear this when you want to feel like the life of the party, but are comfortable fading into the background later in the evening. Not suitable for close encounters. ### Performance Reality Check Longevity is moderate, clinging to the skin for approximately 5 hours. Projection is initially a forceful one arm length, quickly settling into a more intimate skin scent after the first hour. I tested this in a heated office environment, and the sweetness became cloying, even headache-inducing."
Majestic Opulence
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Bottom Line Wearing Majestic Opulence is like admiring a watercolor rendition of an oil painting. You get a suggestion of the overall composition, a hint of the intended grandeur, but lack the depth, texture, and lasting impact of the original. There's a boldness present, but it's undermined by a lack of refinement. This might suit someone who craves the *idea* of luxurious warmth but is willing to sacrifice quality for fleeting similarity. ### Scent Breakdown Majestic Opulence opens with a sharp citrus blast; less the juicy mandarin, more the bitter pith. A ghost of pink pepper adds a fleeting prickle before the incense emerges, tinged with a harsh, almost rubbery note that deviates significantly from the smooth, resinous smokiness I expected. The tobacco in the heart leans heavily into dried pipe tobacco, a little acrid, losing the supple warmth of its inspiration. Saffron peeks through, but lacks nuance. The drydown is where the divergence is most apparent: a synthetic oud battles a plasticky leather accord over a vaguely sweet, but ultimately generic amber base. Where I detect the warmth of well-worn saddle leather in the reference, Majestic Opulence offers something closer to a vinyl car seat on a hot day. ### Performance Reality Check On my skin, Majestic Opulence lasts around 5-6 hours. Projection is moderate for the first hour, extending maybe an arm's length, then quickly settles into a skin scent. I tested this during a busy work day, and again at a relaxed dinner. While it didn't entirely vanish, it became a faint, indistinct presence by the end of either scenario."
Fleur De Baies
Zara
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Is it Worth It? This fragrance would suit casual daytime wear. The candied citrus opening would be fine for running errands or grabbing coffee. Its fleeting projection makes it acceptable for close-quarters scenarios. ### First Impressions & Dry Down Zara's Fleur De Baies bursts open with a candied grapefruit accord, immediately veering away from Widian's I. The pink pepper is amped up, lending a sharp, almost medicinal quality reminiscent of cherry cough syrup. The heart attempts the incense and tobacco blend but falls short; the incense comes across as synthetic, lacking depth, and the tobacco is a faint whisper of pipe tobacco rather than rich, aged leaf. The saffron adds a metallic tinge. The drydown offers a muted oud that mixes with a plasticky amber and a leather accord that is reminiscent of vinyl car seats. It's a pleasant but generic ambery oud, noticeably less complex than its inspiration. ### Longevity & Projection Fleur De Baies lasts approximately 5 hours on skin, projecting moderately within an arm's length for the first hour before quickly settling close to the skin. I tested it at the office during a full day. The projection became a faint skin scent by lunchtime."
Violet Oud
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Final Thoughts Wearing Violet Oud is like attending a formal event in ill-fitting attire. It attempts to evoke sophistication but misses the mark. The gain is a certain boldness in the initial stages, but the loss is nuance and overall refinement. The synthetic components ultimately detract from the intended luxurious experience. ### First Impressions & Dry Down Violet Oud opens with a disconcerting, almost medicinal blast. The promised mandarin and grapefruit manifest as a singular, sharp citrus accord reminiscent of cleaning fluid, underscored by a prickly pink pepper attempting, and failing, to soften the initial harshness. The heart attempts to introduce complexity with incense and tobacco, but the saffron presence is muddled, creating a vague, slightly acrid spice that leans toward stale potpourri. The base reveals the central tension: a synthetic oud note, smelling vaguely of wood polish, clashes with a plasticky leather accord. The amber provides a sickly-sweet, almost cloying counterpoint. I detect only a passing resemblance to I by Widian; the original has a smoother, more refined evolution, whereas this veers into discordant territory. ### The Performance Stats Longevity is deceptive. It remains detectable on skin for a solid 7 hours, however, the projection is minimal; settling into a skin scent within an hour of application. Tested in an indoor, climate-controlled environment and outdoors in moderate temperatures."
Orange Oud
Montagne Parfums
Our objective metric for performance per dollar.
"### Scent Breakdown Orange Oud opens with a blast of candied mandarin – almost sickeningly sweet. There’s a fleeting resemblance to the promised grapefruit, but it quickly morphs into something akin to orange hard candy left in the sun. The pink pepper is present, adding a slight prickle, but it's overwhelmed. The heart attempts to introduce smokiness with incense and tobacco, but the saffron note dominates, smelling slightly metallic and medicinal like iodine. It deviates quite a bit from what I understand of the original, which is far more nuanced. The base is where the real disappointment lies. Instead of a rich, complex oud and leather accord, it's a synthetic approximation, smelling of rubber and cheap amber. ### Final Thoughts This fragrance is for someone who prioritizes strength over sophistication and doesn't mind a rough-around-the-edges composition. Picture a young professional who just landed their first corporate job, wants to project power, but hasn't quite refined their taste. ### Wear time & Sillage Longevity is surprisingly decent, clinging to skin for about six hours. However, projection is nuclear for the first hour, then rapidly fades to a skin scent. I wore this while working from home and it filled the entire room initially, then became a barely-there whisper by lunchtime."
About these I alternatives
Scentonym tracks specific batch variations and reformulation notes. The clones listed above are ranked by community verification score. Prices are updated daily from major retailers.